December 07, 2004

Blacktop Jungle: Snow Big Deal

Christmas lights are appearing throughout the neighborhood, wreaths and giant lighted snowmen are decorating homes, and commercial radio stations are in their second week of torturing us with holiday songs. Yes, it's that magical time that comes only once a year, which we call the Annual Mounting of the Snow Tires.

That coincides with the much-more regularly occurring events we call the Scraping of the Knuckles and the Using of the Very Bad Words.

Each year, I try to wait until as late in the season as possible, mostly because a good pair of winter snowshoes for the ol' sled is fairly expensive, and they wear out quickly on dry pavement. Invariably, I wait too long, and end up putting the snow tires on as it's snowing.

On Sunday, with the weather seeming to turn colder and rain and snow in the forecast, I decided to take a chance.

Naturally, it's rained for the past two days.

Incidentally, there must be something more depressing than a rainy day in December in Western Pennsylvania, but I can't really think of it. It's not bad enough that all of the leaves have fallen off of the trees and are rotting in the gutters, or that we have about six hours of daylight, or that everything has taken on a gray, dirty cast. No, now the sun is blotted out by clouds, and we're cold and wet, to boot. Why have you forsaken us, Joe DeNardo?

It almost makes one long for snow --- getting back the whole snow tire thing that I started out with. Many people believe that front-wheel drive negates the purpose of snow tires. Au contraire, motormouth. All other things being equal, a front-wheel drive car equipped with "all season" tires will have better traction in snow than a rear-wheel drive equipped with "all season" tires --- but a front-wheel drive car with a good set of snow tires will outperform them both. My late grandfather had a front-wheel drive Ford Escort equipped with snow tires that I think would have climbed up the side of an igloo, if you'd let it. It plowed through snow better than some four-wheel drive vehicles.

A few words of explanation are in order before the snow starts flying.

Front-wheel drive means just that; the front wheels propel the car. Probably 60 percent of the cars currently being built are front-wheel drive. (I didn't make any attempt to verify that stat, by the way. I plucked it out of the air.) Front-wheel drive cars have good traction in snow because the heavy engine sits up front, directly over the drive wheels. Rear-wheel drive means the opposite --- the power is transmitted from the engine up front to the wheels in the back via a long drive shaft.

Rear-wheel drive cars are good at lots of things --- most race cars and many performance cars are rear-wheel drive --- but driving in snow isn't necessarily one of them. The heavy motor is up front, and can't provide any weight to help keep the drive wheels on the road. Worse yet, in a really light car, the heavy front end sometimes wants to slide out of the way and swap ends with the rear wheels. That's why putting a 50 pound bag of sand in the trunk of a rear-wheel drive car is often recommended for winter driving. Rear-wheel drive is making a strong comeback --- Chrysler recently re-introduced its first rear-wheel drive sedans in years --- and maybe 30 percent of the cars being built today are rear-wheel drive. Most (if not all) trucks are rear-wheel drive, and they benefit most of all from a bag or two or three of sand in the back, especially if secured with boards and chains over the rear wheels.

Of course, many trucks and SUVs, and maybe 10 percent of passenger cars, have four-wheel drive, which means exactly what it sounds like. Four-wheel drive is not a license to drive like a maniac in the snow, and I know you nuts are out there. A four-wheel drive vehicle driven recklessly in the snow is just as likely to go plowing off the road and into a ditch as any other vehicle; it's just often easier to get a four-wheel drive vehicle back out of the ditch, because you have two more chances that one of your drive wheels will be able to get you out.

Now, back to the tires. Summer tires are just that --- for use in the summer. "All-season" tires aren't, as far as I'm concerned. They should be called "three-season" tires, because they aren't great on ice or snow. Snow tires use softer, stickier rubber --- good for gripping ice, but not very long-wearing --- and they usually have big, blocky treads that are good at digging into loose material.

Snow tires have a couple of drawbacks --- besides the fact that they wear out fairly quickly, they can also screw up a car's handling at high speeds --- but on a rear-wheel drive vehicle like my sleek, gray Mercury, they're essential. And having driven front-wheel drive vehicles both with and without snow tires, they're a useful safety feature, in my never-humble opinion, and well worth the money. A good snow tire should cost between $70 and $90, installed, in my experience. (Personally, I get mine from an independent dealer in Our Fair City that deals in both brand-name and generic tire brands, and I try to stick to American-made tires.)

I also know several people who put snow tires on all four wheels of their cars, on the grounds that steering and braking is improved in deep snow if all four wheels are similarly shod. Mechanics that I've talked to have told me that it doesn't help that much in the kind of snow that Western Pennsylvania usually gets, and that it's a waste of money, but if you drive frequently on unplowed roads, it might be worth the extra cash.

Also, if you don't mind changing your own tires --- or if you know someone who will do the job for you --- you can save time by buying a set of spare wheels for your car and having snow tires mounted on them. (You can get used or new wheels from a good junkyard --- I've bought them from both Spitz Auto Parts in North Huntingdon and Toll Gate in Greensburg --- and most yards will check to figure out what kind of wheels you need, if you don't already know.) That way, you don't have to leave your vehicle at the tire store to have the snow tires mounted; just leave the wheels, and pick them up when you're ready.

As long as you have a good jack and jack stands, and a flat surface to change the tires, you can put the snow tires on at home, when you're good and ready. Obviously, you'll need someplace to store the two tires you're not using; that would be a real problem from apartment dwellers, I suppose. (I guess you could prop them up in the living room and drape spider plants over them, maybe, or call them outsider art.)

Anyway, do you run snow tires on your car? And what kind of vehicle is it? I'd be interested in hearing from you. Drop me an email at jt 3 y at dementia dot org, or leave your information below by clicking on the "comment" link.

...

This is one of a new series of entries I'm going to be writing called "Blacktop Jungle," which was the name of an automotive column I wrote years ago for the Observer-Reporter in Washington. Look for another one soon on winter driving tips and techniques. Eventually, I hope to expand "Blacktop Jungle" to a new section of Tube City Online that will also include helpful shortcuts around Western Pennsylvania. (You can submit those, too!)

...

In other news, remember yesterday's rant about bad publicity being aimed at Our Fair City, and the bad image it gets in the media?

Some timing I've got, huh? Yoi and double yoi:

Attorney General Jerry Pappert today announced that agents from his Bureau of Narcotics Investigation (BNI) have intercepted a shipment of 11 kilograms of cocaine and have arrested two McKeesport, Allegheny County residents on charges of possession with intent to deliver the drug.
Pappert identified the defendants as Gregory T. Armstrong, 36, 3010 Grover St. McKeesport and James E. Jones, 45, 1026 Walnut St., McKeesport.

Talk about your snow. Estimated value on the purloined powder is about $1 million.

Speaking of mood-altering substances, if there's one thing I love, it isn't state-controlled liquor monopolies. (Tip of the Tube City hard hat to Cope.)

Meanwhile, researchers in Picksberg have taken bold steps toward preventing another monkey shortage by successfully cloning monkey embryos. This should shore up America's strategic monkey reserve and prevent terrorists and rogue nations from exploiting a monkey gap.

Some people have asked why, if we needed extra monkey embryos, we couldn't have just let the monkeys create them --- it being one of the things that monkeys (and other primates) are good at. Personally, I'm glad that Western Pennsylvania is working to protect America by ensuring that we remain safe, free and full of monkeys in the 21st century.

Posted by jt3y at December 7, 2004 12:57 AM
Comments

Over the weekend I put snow tires on my '94 Acura Integra. Two snow tires up front, two all seasons in the back. They're mounted to 14" steel rims, my summer tires are on 16" aluminum rims. It was a bit time consuming, but I did it myself in about one hour.

Posted by: Wade Massie at December 7, 2004 11:52 AM

It's bad enought that Maryland is one of those 24 states in the booze fight. Montgomery County, MD has an old post-Prohibition law that gives the county total control over ALL booze sales in the county. The county buys all the alcohol. Beer & wine stores then have to buy their stock from the County warehouse. Hard stuff is only sold in county stores. Since we border Prince Georges County and Washington DC (both of whom are more enlightend, and cheaper!!) the county deployes the "booze cops" during this time of year to monitor sales at stores just outside the border and ticket and confiscate any booze brought into the county. So if you saw a good write-up in Wine Spectator about a particularly nice Cheateau de Neuf Swill du 1999, and the county doesn't stock it, you can't legally get it.

Posted by: Deane M. at December 7, 2004 12:40 PM

Recent studies confirm that the American driving public is fed up with front-wheel drive cars. Of course, this is no secret.

Everyone knows front-wheel drive was a fad, like gull-wing car doors and dashboard-mounted gearshifts. Motoring in America, especially with high performance cars like, (insert your preference of Ford or GM or Chrysler here), has always meant rear-wheel drive--the laws of physics be damned.

If God had intended us to have traction in snow, we would've been born with shoeshoes instead of feet. I say long live rear-wheel drive!

To hell with indoor plumbing! Ban penicillin!

Posted by: Prof. Quackenbush at December 7, 2004 01:46 PM

Probably not the kind of quantifiable data you're looking for, but it IS honest, and that should count for something....

I have absolutely no idea what kind of tires I have on my 2000 Grand Am.

I do know that I need new ones, though. The helpful state inspection guys told me that, and the living proof is that I've been sliding all over the road for the past two weeks.

I will boldly march into my local purveyor of tires, pronounce my self unknowledgeable about tires and ready for raping, and then let them have their way with me.

But one thing I WON'T do is go to that particular retailer you recently referred to as "Broils." That story irked me enough that they'll never get another penny of my money.

Posted by: Bob at December 7, 2004 03:24 PM

Geez, Professor Quackenbush, are you off your meds again? Some of the most popular (and expensive) cars being sold today are RWD:

Chrysler 300M: Rear-wheel drive

Dodge Magnum: Rear-wheel drive

Infiniti G35: Rear-wheel drive

Lexus IS-300: Rear-wheel drive

Cadillac CTS: Rear-wheel drive

Lincoln LS: Rear-wheel drive

Mercedes-Benz C230, Chevrolet Corvette, BMW 745, BMW 760, Jaguar S-Type ... well, you get the idea. So why don't I see all these Mercedes-Benzes and BMWs stuck on the side of the road?

You need to get out more, Professor.

Posted by: Webmaster at December 7, 2004 03:32 PM


I'm gonna put snow tires on the '99 Grand Am's front tires. I do that every year, no problem. But now I also have a '03 Honda Pilot. Its 4WD and has all-seasons, but I'm contemplating putting some snow-goers on it. But I'm also afraid of that bill.

Posted by: Sean at December 7, 2004 11:55 PM
Post a comment









Remember personal info?










IMPORTANT: Comments posted at the Tube City Almanac become property of the Almanac, and may be edited for content or deleted if found to be libelous. The Almanac conforms to the standards for accuracy and fairness proscribed in the Associated Press Stylebook and Briefing on Media Law. Opinions expressed by commenters are not necessarily those of Jason Togyer, and do not necessarily represent those of the University of Pittsburgh, Dementia Unlimited, or any other organization. Except where noted, all contents are Copyright © 2004-2007 Jason Togyer, all rights reserved, and may not be reproduced in whole or part without express permission. Further information available at our disclaimers page.