Tube City Almanac

May 10, 2011

Briefly Noted: City Controller Launches Own Garbage Probe

(News)

Bypassing the mayor and city council, Controller Ray Malinchak has launched his own investigation into McKeesport's garbage collection practices.

In a press release, Malinchak announced Monday that he had hired Corporate Security and Investigations of Monaca, Beaver County, to find out why the amount of garbage collected in the city has gone up about 20 percent since the contract was switched to Clairton-based Nickolich Sanitation. No timetable was outlined in the release.

Malinchak argued that he is authorized under McKeesport's Home Rule Charter "to review and investigate current fiscal operations and affairs of the city."

. . .

"The city controller, with significant assistance from CSI a professional investigative firm, will fulfill these authorized responsibilities by seeking to isolate the causes for a precipitous over 2,000 tons increase in 2009 trash invoices," Malinchak said in his statement.

The city's home rule charter gives the controller authority to "review or investigate any fiscal operation of the City including any board, commission, authority or agency utilizing City funds upon majority action of City Council."

While the charter does not give the controller authority to appropriate money, it does entitle him "to his actual expenses incurred in the performance of his duties," which presumably means taxpayers will be paying for CSI's services.

City council in April voted to investigate the increase. In May, after Mayor Regis McLaughlin recommended the city hire CSI at a cost of $5,000, Council President Mike Cherepko said the city would instead seek competitive bids and award a contract at the June council meeting, or at a special meeting before June.

. . .

But Malinchak's announcement Monday also carried political overtones. Although he is not a candidate in this month's Democratic primary, Malinchak was rumored to be considering a run for mayor.

Indeed, the controller used part of his press release to attack Cherepko, former Mayor Jim Brewster, and city employees for delaying the release of the so-called "Delta report" into McKeesport's finances; and to criticize the city for not competitively bidding the services of its health insurance broker.

Cherepko, who's the endorsed Democratic candidate for mayor and a ally of now-state Sen. Brewster, last week said Malinchak and others were using the garbage hauling contract to score political points.

Malinchak claimed that Cherepko "(abused) his discretion" by not holding a vote to hire CSI at the May 4 council meeting. "The assistance of CSI in this complex matter is in the best interest of the City, and will afford government transparency, and ensure Controller autonomy," Malinchak said in his statement.

. . .

CSI, formerly known as Gentile-Meinert & Associates, was paid $5,500 in 2010 by the West Mifflin Area School District to investigate hiring, personnel and financial practices of the late Patrick Risha, former district superintendent. The company has also performed work for other local municipalities.

Last week, a lawyer for Nickolich Sanitation said the city's trash collections have increased because the company is collecting more garbage than the previous waste hauler, Allied Waste Services. Nickolich picks up loose trash that Allied didn't collect, including construction waste and furniture, said attorney John Linkosky.

Calling some of the comments made by city officials "defamatory and slanderous," Linkosky also attacked Malinchak and city council members for not calling Nickolich to discuss their concerns before airing them in the media.

Linkosky invited city officials to ride with Nickolich crews and inspect the tonnage slips when the trash trucks are weighed.







Feedback on “Briefly Noted: City Controller Launches Own Garbage Probe”

Malinchak seems to have gone off the deep end, sending press releases about every little thing all the time, attacking people through the media, etc. In fact, he just confirmed the stereotype of McKeesport politics being a circus. Glad I got out before I was shot out of a cannon.
Adam Spate - May 10, 2011




The sanitation department and the city where both advised at least 6 weeks ago that they needed to verify boundary lines between McKeesport and White Oak on 1000 block of Bennet St in the Fawcett Plan area as ensure they were not picking up White Oak trash by mistake.
Joe Ukasik - May 12, 2011




Personal information

Due to abuse by a handful of people, we will no longer accept anonymous comments. You may request to use a pen name or to have your real name withheld, but you may not comment anonymously, and you must give us a verifiable email address and/or phone number.







Remember your information?
Comment

Small print: All html tags except <b> and <i> will be removed from your comment. You can make links by just typing the url or mail-address.

Terms of Service: Tube City Community Media Inc. encourages discussion and debate, and welcomes dissenting opinions. However, the corporation cannot and will not vouch for the accuracy of comments.

Opinions expressed in the comments are those of the posters, and do not reflect those of Tube City Community Media Inc., its directors or affiliates.

Under 47 U.S.C. 230, the corporation is not legally responsible for opinions expressed in the comments. However: We reserve the right to delete comments for any or no reason, including comments that are libelous, defamatory, infringing, inappropriate or offensive. We also reserve the right to ban individuals with or without warning.

Posting a comment at www.tubecityonline.com gives the corporation a perpetual, free license to reprint or republish that comment.

Posting a comment at www.tubecityonline.com or any related site operated by Tube City Community Media Inc. implies acceptance of these terms.